The closest thing to Total War on the market right now is Knights of Honor II: Sovereign, which runs a live map of medieval Europe and drops you straight into real-time battles from it. The game most lapsed campaigners actually stay in, though, is Mount & Blade II: Bannerlord, because it treats the campaign as a sandbox instead of a chessboard. Both scratch the same itch from opposite ends.

What follows are five games like Total War that keep the two-layer structure intact, ranked by how well they handle the part Creative Assembly still does best: the moment a few thousand men meet on a hill and one line breaks first. Pure base-building RTS is a different appetite, and the Age of Empires alternatives cover that better. If it is the turn-based empire layer you miss rather than the fighting, start with the Civilization-style picks instead.

1. Mount & Blade II: Bannerlord

Buy this one if what you want is the battle, not the spreadsheet. Bannerlord puts you inside the fight as a single soldier who happens to be giving orders, and at $49.99 on Steam it is the deepest combat model in this group. The default battle-size slider runs to 1,000 troops on screen, and cavalry actually behaves like cavalry, which means a badly timed charge into spears costs you the wing.

The honest weakness is the campaign layer. Diplomacy is shallow next to a Total War grand campaign, sieges still produce pathfinding comedy, and once your kingdom passes about a dozen fiefs the management turns into clicking through menus to stop lords defecting. Bannerlord is a great battle game with an adequate strategy game bolted on, and most people decide that trade is worth it somewhere around hour fifty.

2. Knights of Honor II: Sovereign

This is the structural clone, and the one to pick if you specifically miss the rhythm of managing a kingdom and then fighting for it. It costs $44.99 on Steam and covers all of medieval Europe with a royal court of marshals, merchants, clerics, and spies who each need a job. The map runs in real time with a pause key rather than in turns, so a siege in Aragon and a peasant revolt in Bohemia can go wrong in the same thirty seconds.

The battles are where it falls short of the thing it is imitating. Armies cap out at nine units per marshal, the unit roster is thin compared to any Total War title from the last decade, and fights resolve in a couple of minutes without much room for a clever flank. Treat the combat as a competent tiebreaker rather than the main course. If the era matters more than the scale, the wider medieval strategy roundup has options that go deeper on the period.

3. Ultimate General: Civil War

Nothing else on this list gives you battles this large for $29.99. Ultimate General: Civil War fights the entire 1861 to 1865 war as one campaign, and by the back half you are moving corps of tens of thousands of men across ground that takes real minutes to cross. Morale, fatigue, ammunition, and line of sight do the work that unit counters do elsewhere, so a fresh brigade hitting an exhausted flank ends the argument immediately.

The cost is everything outside the battlefield. There is no city building, no diplomacy, and no map painting, just a recruitment and supply screen between engagements. The interface looks like a 2017 indie release because it is one, and the campaign has a well-known difficulty wall where a run of good results scales the enemy army faster than your budget scales yours. Anyone who came for the fighting and nothing else will read that as a feature. It is the purest real-time strategy experience on this list, with the campaign layer cut down to a supply clerk and a recruitment budget.

4. Company of Heroes 3

Pick this if the Italian campaign map sells you on the loop and you can live with squads instead of regiments. Company of Heroes 3 wraps a turn-based invasion of Italy around real-time battles you can pause mid-fight to issue orders, which is the most Total War thing Relic has ever shipped. Supply lines, airfields, and partisan companies on the campaign map genuinely change what you face when you drop into a fight.

At $59.99 it is also the most expensive entry here, and the scale gap is real. A big Company of Heroes engagement is maybe forty men, not four thousand, and the campaign AI puts up little resistance once you understand how it allocates its reserves. The multiplayer is the long-term draw rather than the campaign, so buy it for the versus mode or do not buy it at all. If what you wanted was a war that keeps grinding on while you are logged off, the longer online war campaigns do that job for less money.

5. Manor Lords

Manor Lords is the pick for the half of the Total War audience that always liked the settlement screen more than the swords. It sells for $39.99 on Steam and models a single medieval region down to ox carts, burgage plot extensions, and whether your families can afford firewood in February. Raising a militia from that population and marching it out to meet a bandit lord carries weight precisely because you know what every one of those men was doing last week.

Be clear-eyed about the state of it. Manor Lords has been in early access since April 2024 with no announced 1.0 date, and combat is still the least developed system in the game. The 2026 updates have gone almost entirely into the economy, adding cattle breeding, cheese production, and a split between basic and advanced construction. Buy it as a village simulator that occasionally fights, and the battles will feel like a bonus rather than a letdown.

Which One Should You Actually Buy

Sort by which half of Total War you would defend in an argument. If it is the battles, Bannerlord and Ultimate General are the only two that will satisfy you, and Ultimate General wins outright on raw scale for twenty dollars less. If it is the campaign map and the feeling of running a kingdom badly, Knights of Honor II is the answer and the small battles will stop bothering you after a few hours. Company of Heroes 3 is the one to skip unless the modern setting is the specific draw, since its price and its scale point in opposite directions. Manor Lords is a different game wearing a similar coat, and it is the best of the five if you were always the player who spent forty minutes on province management before pressing end turn. None of the five replaces Total War outright, so pick the half you actually care about and stop shopping, which is how every ranking on Strategygame.org is built.

Frequently Asked Questions